The Historical Error in the J.Lo Movie ‘Boy Next Door’ Had Critics Laughing


The Boy Subsequent Door is a 2015 stalker thriller starring Jennifer Lopez. It’s a few lady who falls in love with an adolescent solely to be taught he’s homicidal. It’s not too totally different from Deadly Attraction or Primary Intuition.

Aside from one scene. The Boy Subsequent Door accommodates a sequence so preposterous it stands as one of many nice historic errors in motion pictures. One way or the other, Hollywood made an error which some middle-schoolers might determine.

Jennifer Lopez in a blue outfit | Gustavo Caballero/Getty Pictures for Common Photos

A Jennifer Lopez film, Greek poetry, and a hilariously inaccurate scene

First, a quick historical past lesson. The Iliad is an epic Greek poem attributed to the legendary poet Homer. It’s one of the vital revered poems ever written. It was composed round 762 B.C. The Iliad initially was carried down by means of oral custom earlier than being written down.

The poem’s age makes a scene in The Boy Subsequent Door baffling. Within the scene, Noah Sandborn (performed by Ryan Guzman) provides Claire Peterson (performed by Lopez) a first-edition copy of the Iliad. It appears like some other previous ebook you would possibly see at a yard sale.

This is mindless. There aren’t any existent “first editions” of the Iliad. In the event that they existed, they’d be on some type of papyrus. They certainly wouldn’t seem like each different ebook in your native thrift retailer.

How critics and followers reacted to this scene

The notorious Iliad scene from The Boy Subsequent Door

Many critics and followers discovered the scene hilarious. To many, it appeared inexplicable. The sequence definitely didn’t assist The Boy Subsequent Door‘s poor essential standing.

Apparently, The Boy Next Door had some affect on customers. The movie was launched to theaters in Jan. 2015. From then to Feb. 2015, quite a few prospects regarded for first-edition copies of the Iliad on AbeBooks.

Did these customers actually suppose a first-edition copy of the Iliad was only a mouseclick away? Richard Davies of AbeBooks felt prospects have been simply excited by discovering the version of the Iliad Lopez’s character obtained as a present. Oddly sufficient, AbeBooks didn’t appear to have a replica of that version, main Davies to marvel if the copy within the movie was only a prop. Annie Brandt, one of many movie’s propmasters, stated the version of the Iliad used within the movie was actual.

The film’s director speaks out

Rob Cohen in a white go well with | Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic

On this age of social media, filmmakers typically reply on to critiques of their movies. Rob Cohen, the director of The Boy Subsequent Door, was no exception. Cohen stated he wrote the scene into the movie’s script.

In keeping with BuzzFeed, he stated there was an upside to all of the criticism the movie obtained. “That tells me they’re watching and listening and considering and so they’re engaged; even when they suppose we’re idiots, I’m not an fool. I’m a ebook collector and I learn about first editions.”

Cohen stated he was absolutely conscious unique copies of the Iliad don’t exist. He was making an attempt to say that Lopez’s character obtained a replica of the Iliad which was the primary version of a brand new reprint. This makes whole sense. Perhaps an additional line or two within the script would have clarified his intentions.

Additionally see: Could Jennifer Lopez Be the Next Batman?